Godzdogz

Godzdogz

The blog of the Dominican student brothers at Blackfriars, Oxford.

Built on the four pillars of our Dominican life – preaching, prayer, study, and community – Godzdogz offers many resources for exploring the Catholic Faith today.
Read more.

What has racism got to do with me?

Saturday, June 13, 2020

By Br John Bernard Church, O.P | Talking about racism is difficult, because it is unavoidably personal and quickly creates charged conversations. But these have to be had, and it seems a bit of theology might help get things going.

Why is it so difficult to talk about racism? The fate of statues and incidents of violence seem to dominate much of the conversation surrounding the recent protests. Once you add the context of a global pandemic and three months of lockdown a whole range of controversial issues draw attention away from having the conversation that really matters.

It’s an awkward conversation, not least because it is so highly charged. And it’s not that the other topics aren’t important to discuss, but we mustn’t avoid the difficult one. 

To some what I intend to say will all be incredibly obvious, but to many others, myself included, asking the right questions doesn’t come naturally. And it seems a bit of theology might help get that conversation going.

To begin with, for those who haven’t scrolled down to the bio at the bottom of this piece, I’ll just point out that I’m white. I have a white racial identity. And here begins the awkwardness, both for me and no doubt many reading this. As a white person, I’m very unaccustomed to talking about myself as having a racial identity: the colour of my skin doesn’t consciously shape my day-to-day.

And being white is not a neutral fact about me. Put in the context of my almost entirely white upbringing and social surroundings, both past and present, the positions of authority I directly experience and the role models I am presented with, it undeniably shapes who I am. Thus understanding what it means to experience the world as a white person in the UK today is a necessary step for me to understand racism, and understand the experiences of those who aren’t white.

This is why talking about race is difficult. As obvious as it is that racism exists, even at an explicit and grave level, it is easy to think it doesn’t directly concern me: I can rest content that I’m a good person, I have black friends, I love everyone the same, and so on. It’s the usual list of reactionary responses. I’m not bigoted, or ignorant, or prejudiced, I’m completely horrified at the treatment of George Floyd and Ahmaud Arbery and others, therefore I can’t be racist.

But this sets up a false dichotomy. To assume only a bad person can be racist is to forget that our moral character is made up of far more than our conscious states. It includes the unconscious as well. Our inclinations are conditioned by factors not of our choosing, by our genetics, our upbringing, our culture, as well as by conscious choice and informed decision. A throwaway generalisation or an instinctive assumption is the product of a character formed by both the conscious and the unconscious.

And this is where structural racism comes in, the systems which perpetuate racial group inequity. A society that has evolved out of a history which has affirmed the superiority of white people, that has benefitted from colonialism and slavery, is going to have inherited systems and institutions that are racially prejudiced. Growing up in such a society, immersed in its systems and unaware of its problems, a character will be conditioned by its structures. 

But again the instinct is to say that, even if I’m willing to acknowledge the fact of structural racism, it’s not something I participate in. Society has its flaws, but I’m a good person and I’m not racist.

It can perhaps be an especially difficult subject among people of faith, the Baptised who have opened their hearts to the work of sanctifying grace. Surely a life that is entirely Christ-centred leaves no room for racism? Well, yes, of course it doesn’t. But that is exactly why this question should make the reality a lot clearer for us, because we know what is meant by original sin.

Original sin, the primeval sin of disobedience, is not a ‘something’ that is transmitted, but a state we contract. It’s not a sin we personally commit, but the internal disharmony, the lack of original justice, that marks our nature. It may not be of our choosing, but we are naturally inclined towards sin.

And this sin is not merely personal, it is not just individuals who are marked by these wounds. As the Catechism puts it, sins “give rise to social situations and institutions that are contrary to the divine goodness”, generating “structures of sin”. Society fosters collective habits or characteristics that incline its members towards ignorance or selfishness or prejudice. Let’s be clear: structural racism has its root in original sin.

This is why the fight against racial discrimination is at an initial level a spiritual one. Just as the first stage in the spiritual life is knowing I am a sinner in need of God’s love, and central to an examination of conscience is asking how I consciously or subconsciously participate in structures of sin, so it is true of structural racism: I have to ask myself difficult questions about inherited biases. Avoiding those questions, not seeking to be informed on the issue, or dismissing unfamiliar voices or points of view, only serves to limit the full flowering of divine charity within me.

***

There is a further consideration, however, that is important. Many might be worried that such a response, and the sort of argument I have sketched, is buying into a whole narrative: it is the language of a ‘woke’, secular culture with an anthropology that stands in stark contrast to that of the Church. This fear is evident in a hesitancy to support the Black Lives Matter organisation, since to many its mission is too closely tied to questionable positions on sexuality and gender.

But there are two points to be made here. Firstly, we have to seek common ground where we are able, working together for the common good in a spirit of constructive cooperation. These topics are highly complex and nuanced and there are no simple answers. Dismissing and disengaging with the mission of a whole movement because we can’t agree with it on every point is simply to avoid the issue at hand.

Secondly, and more importantly, questions about race and racial identity are of course inextricably linked to those surrounding sexuality and gender and the right to life. They are all variations on asking what it means to be a human person, looking at distinct and discrete topics, but ones that frequently overlap. The richness of a Catholic anthropology is indispensable to the public discourse, as the only means of making complete sense of the inherent worth and dignity of every human being. As individuals and as a Church we have to be part of those conversations.

Yet unless we seek common ground and get the basics right about race, we risk not being taken seriously on any issue of human identity or social justice. To avoid asking the question am I racist, to avoid confronting my own unconscious bias, precludes me from joining the conversation.

Where to begin? The conversation is difficult, and the path long. But, in the words of Austin Channing Brown, “our only chance at dismantling racial injustice is being more curious about its origins than we are worried about our own comfort.” I am no expert on this and have lots of reading to do, but here are some resources I intend to look at which are likely to bring a new perspective:

This list is by no means comprehensive, please do add to it in the comments below.


Br John Bernard Church O.P.

Br John Bernard, raised a Catholic by an English father and Dutch mother, first encountered the Dominicans at Blackfriars while studying Classics at the University of Oxford, and entered the noviciate in 2018. An attraction to religious life initially grew out of time spent working with the Missionaries of Charity, which then crystallised into a Dominican vocation through a desire to integrate the contemplative life with preaching and study. Based on his recent reading, he looks forward to delving further into St John of the Cross and the Carmelite mystics, as well as combining his preaching vocation with a love of the outdoors. | john.church@english.op.org

MORE ON: CURRENT AFFAIRS

Image attribution: 

https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:People_March_for_Racial_Justice.jpg

Comments

Anonymous commented on 14-Jun-2020 03:15 AM
Sara Ahmed, On Being Included https://www.dukeupress.edu/on-being-included
Jay Bernard, Surge https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/111/1116412/surge/9781784742614.html
Zong!, M. NourbeSe Philip https://www.nourbese.com/poetry/zong-3/
Claudia Rankine, Citizen https://www.graywolfpress.org/books/citizen
Nikesh Shukla, ed., The Good Immigrant http://www.nikesh-shukla.com/the-good-immigrant
Begley commented on 14-Jun-2020 02:43 PM
Excellent article John , thought provoking and an article I will use for self Reflection in terms of where I am in the current conversation about race.
Thomas
Juliana Crestani commented on 15-Jun-2020 10:55 AM
Please include Thomas Sowell in your reading list. He's an economist and social theorist with a lot to say about race and public education. I find his voice particularly relevant because he grew up in very difficult circumstances, and was a high school dropout before becoming an academic. He has some quite impressive essays and interviews (sadly I have not checked his books yet but I plan to). You can easily find them on his blog and around YouTube.
Robert commented on 15-Jun-2020 12:47 PM
Interesting and very timely piece Br John. Thank you.

Readers may be interested to have a look at the National Museum of African American History and Culture Portal 'Talking about Race' which can be found here:
https://nmaahc.si.edu/about/news/national-museum-african-american-history-and-culture-releases-talking-about-race-web

The portal helps people explore issues of Race, Racism and Racial Identity. It is, of course, American but racism knows no national boundaries. The portal has some excellent and easily understood research from leading academics, activists, historians both white and black including Desmond Tutu. The aim is to educate and it is worth a spending time with.
Mark commented on 07-Jul-2020 08:54 PM
We are all children of God.

Created equal and in Gods image.

ALL racial discourse is a denial of this truth.

Beware of Godless Marxists hiding behind the divisive racial discourse of our times.

God bless us all.

Post a Comment


Captcha Image
Follow us
Responding to Coronavirus

Responding to Coronavirus

Meet the Student Brothers

Meet the Student Brothers

News

News

Featured Series

Featured Series

Recent posts


Tags


Liturgical index


All tags & authors


Archive

Upcoming events

View the full calendar